The West has a frozen and false idea of India | Current Affairs | Vision IAS

Daily News Summary

Get concise and efficient summaries of key articles from prominent newspapers. Our daily news digest ensures quick reading and easy understanding, helping you stay informed about important events and developments without spending hours going through full articles. Perfect for focused and timely updates.

News Summary

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat

The West has a frozen and false idea of India

2 min read

India's Global Narrative and Media Influence

India's military successes, such as Operation Sindoor, have not been matched by a successful global narrative. There is a growing concern that while India has achieved military victories, it has lost the narrative battle on the international stage.

Need for a Global Media Presence

  • Lack of Global Media Channel: Unlike BBC, CNN, or Al Jazeera, India lacks a significant global media presence. Efforts to establish an independent global digital news platform in 2016 did not materialize.
  • Impact of Global Media: The international media often portrays Indian narratives inaccurately, emphasizing negative stereotypes such as Hindu nationalism and overlooking India's perspective on terrorism.

Challenges in Global Perception

  • Narrative Discrepancy: Movies and media frequently portray India negatively, influencing global perception against India.
  • Gell-Mann Amnesia Effect: Even if the US media's credibility is questioned, misinformation about India is still often believed.
  • Gap in Storytelling: India's narrative is not effectively communicated to the global public; interactions are limited to official visits rather than engaging broader audiences.

Efforts to Change the Narrative

  • Foreign Investments: Other countries invest heavily in media and education to shape narratives in their favor within the US, as evidenced by Qatar's influence.
  • Historical Perceptions: India's global image has remained unchanged since the 1920s, and foundational changes to this perception have not been actively pursued.
  • Cultural Factors: India lacks a compelling story that resonates internationally, partly due to cultural tendencies not to impose narratives on others.

Media and Cultural Dominance

  • Religious and Cultural Roots: Western media's narrative dominance is not only technological but rooted in culturally propagated religions, with well-organized institutions promoting specific causes.
  • India's Cultural Transition: Indian narratives, such as the sage Narada, have been culturally diminished over time.

The Battle for Global Attention

  • Media Influence and Bias: International media figures often mock and misrepresent India, as seen in reactions to events such as the Pulwama attack.
  • Importance of Narrative: In the modern interconnected world, controlling the narrative is crucial for international perception and influence.

The commentary suggests that India must strategically develop a cohesive and compelling global narrative to counteract inaccuracies and biases in international media representations.

  • Tags :
  • Operation Sindoor
  • Gell-Mann Amnesia Effect
Subscribe for Premium Features