Article 142: Judicial Activism vs. Judicial Overreach | Current Affairs | Vision IAS

Upgrade to Premium Today

Start Now
MENU
Home
Quick Links

High-quality MCQs and Mains Answer Writing to sharpen skills and reinforce learning every day.

Watch explainer and thematic concept-building videos under initiatives like Deep Dive, Master Classes, etc., on important UPSC topics.

A short, intensive, and exam-focused programme, insights from the Economic Survey, Union Budget, and UPSC current affairs.

ESC

In Summary

  • SC declared Right to Safe Travel on National Highways as fundamental under Article 21, using Article 142 powers.
  • Article 142 empowers SC to deliver complete justice where laws fail, but faces criticism for potential judicial overreach.
  • Judicial overreach concerns include violating separation of powers, reduced accountability, lack of expertise, and ignoring executive constraints.

In Summary

Using its power under Article 142, the Supreme Court of India recently declared the Right to safe travel on National Highways as a fundamental right, as an integral component of the Right to Life under Article 21.

  • The Court issued wide-ranging directives and held that providing safe, well-maintained, and motorable roads is a binding constitutional duty of the State, moving it beyond a mere policy objective.

About Article 142

  • Under the Article, SC is empowered to pass necessary orders or decree to delivercomplete justice where existing laws fail to provide a specific remedy. 
  • Not available to High courts: These powers under Article 142 are constitutionally conferred only on SC. 
  • Significance: Fills legislative vacuums if a situation arises where a gross injustice is apparent but there is no explicit law, Article 142 allows the Court to step in and provide an immediate remedy.
    • E.g. Vishaka Guidelines (1997) formulated to tackle sexual harassment at workplaces as there was a complete absence of statutory law at the time.
  • Criticism: While a ‘constitutional safety valve’ to legal gaps, it may cause judicial overreach upon Executive or Legislature. 
    • Judicial Overreach refers to a situation where judiciary crosses its constitutional boundary and interferes in the functions of executive or legislature. 

Concerns associated with Judicial Overreach 

  • Violation of the Separation of Powers: E.g. SC set up the Lodha Panel to reform Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI).
  • Reduced accountability: As principle of checks and balances is diluted. E.g. SC struck down National Judicial appointments commission (2015) to maintain its dominance in judicial appointments.
  • Lack of Subject-Matter Expertise: SC invoked article 142 to ban liquor sale within 500 meters of any national or state highway (Tamil Nadu Vs K. Balu) led to overnight job losses.
  • Ignoring Executive Constraints: Courts may issue directives without considering resource or infrastructure limits.
    • E.g. MC Mehta vs UoI (2018): SC invoked Article 142 to ban sale of BS-IV vehicles, ignoring the government’s grace period imposing logistical and financial constraints. 
Watch Video News Today

Explore Related Content

Discover more articles, videos, and terms related to this topic

RELATED VIDEOS

1
Lateral Entry

Lateral Entry

YouTube HD

RELATED TERMS

3

BS-IV vehicles

Refers to vehicles that meet Bharat Stage IV (BS-IV) emission standards. The Supreme Court invoked Article 142 to ban the sale of BS-IV vehicles, aiming to curb pollution, despite logistical and financial challenges for manufacturers and consumers.

National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC)

An erstwhile proposed constitutional body intended to replace the collegium system for the appointment and transfer of judges in India. The Supreme Court struck down the NJAC Act in 2015, asserting its dominance in judicial appointments.

Vishaka Guidelines

A set of guidelines formulated by the Supreme Court of India in 1997 to address sexual harassment at the workplace, in the absence of specific statutory law at the time. These guidelines were a significant application of Article 142.

Title is required. Maximum 500 characters.

Search Notes

Filter Notes

Loading your notes...
Searching your notes...
Loading more notes...
You've reached the end of your notes

No notes yet

Create your first note to get started.

No notes found

Try adjusting your search criteria or clear the search.

Saving...
Saved

Please select a subject.

Referenced Articles

linked

No references added yet