Select Your Preferred Language

Please choose your language to continue.

Can Guv Not Examine Legislative Competence of Bills? SC to States | Current Affairs | Vision IAS

Daily News Summary

Get concise and efficient summaries of key articles from prominent newspapers. Our daily news digest ensures quick reading and easy understanding, helping you stay informed about important events and developments without spending hours going through full articles. Perfect for focused and timely updates.

News Summary

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat

Can Guv Not Examine Legislative Competence of Bills? SC to States

2 min read

Role of Governor in presidential reference

The five-member Constitution bench of the Supreme Court is reviewing a presidential reference concerning the powers of the President and governors regarding state legislature bills. Key issues include:

Key Issues and Queries

  • Governor's Role: The bench, led by Chief Justice BR Gavai, questioned whether governors can examine the legislative competence of a bill passed by the state legislature and if they can deny assent if the bill conflicts with Central legislation. 
  • Governor as Postman: There is a debate whether governors should merely act as a postman, granting assent without examination. 

Arguments from States

  • Undermine the Constitution: Karnataka, West Bengal, and Himachal Pradesh argue that the presidential reference could undermine the Constitution by appealing against a previous Supreme Court decision. 
  • Hindrance in governance: States contends that the Constitution is a dynamic document and that governors should not hinder its functioning.
  • Public's will: Allowing a governor to permanently withhold a bill disrupts democratic processes and nullifies the public's will. 

Previous Court Rulings

  • April Ruling: The Supreme Court set timelines for governors' assent to state legislature bills, which is now being contested. 
  • Final Arbiter: Courts are considered the ultimate authority on constitutional matters, reinforcing democratic strength. 

In conclusion, the bench is examining whether timelines should be imposed on governors and the president regarding their assent to state legislature bills, considering the constitution’s flexibility and the preservation of democratic principles.

  • Tags :
  • Governor
  • presidential reference
Subscribe for Premium Features