Philanthropy: A Moral Imperative for Social Good | Current Affairs | Vision IAS
Monthly Magazine Logo

Table of Content

    Philanthropy: A Moral Imperative for Social Good

    Posted 16 Apr 2025

    Updated 22 Apr 2025

    5 min read

    Introduction

    "Service to others is the rent you pay for your room here on earth." – Muhammad Ali. This sentiment is reflected in India's growing philanthropic landscape. According to the India Philanthropy Report 2025, philanthropic funding in India is rising primarily driven by corporate social responsibility (CSR) spending, contributions from ultra-high-net-worth individuals (UHNIs), and a rising culture of giving among the middle class. Philanthropy has been a part of many cultures from the ancient times to the modern era. Let's see what it really means in present context.

    Philanthropy in modern context

    The word philanthropy literally means 'love of mankind'. It embodies the benevolent practice of voluntarily donating financial resources to various type of institutions (such as educational, social welfare, scientific etc.) to promote wellbeing and happiness of one's fellow-men.

    • Unlike charity, which provides immediate relief to individuals, philanthropy aims for large-scale, long-term and social impact changes which can uplift entire communities.

    Philosophical Basis of Philanthropy

    Indian Perspective

    • Chanakya's Arthashastra: Donate 1/6th revenue for public welfare.
    • Vivekananda's  Daridra Narayana: Serving poor is worshipping God.
    • Gandhiji's Trusteeship Theory:  Wealthy must act as merely trustees of societal wealth.
    • Religious:-
      • Hinduism: Concepts of daana (giving) and dakshina (alms) 
      • Islam:  zakaat (prescribed offerings ) & sadaqaat (voluntary offerings)
      • Buddhism: bhiksha (alms)
      • Sikhism: langar (community kitchens).

    Western Perspective

    • Consequentialist View (Virtue ethics):  Generosity and compassion are important virtues.
    • Kantian Ethics (Moral Obligation): It is our duty to be beneficient.
    • Rawl's Theory (Justice as fairness): Prioritization of the most disadvantaged sections.
    • Utilitarianism: maximize well-being for greatest number.
    • Libertarianism: They emphasize moral superiority of philanthropy as compared to government-provided assistance. 

    Multifaceted aspects of Philanthropy

    Philanthropic Ethics

    Customary

    Entrepreneurial

    Spiritual/Effective Altruism

    Definition

    It focuses on benevolence by showing adequate concern. 

    Well-conceived, sustainable social projects that create opportunities for upward social mobility.

    Long-term initiatives aimed at addressing institutional voids. It is inspired by cultural values and religious principles.

    Objectives

    Ameliorative

    Transformational

    Developmental

    Strategy

    Opportunity Driven

    Change Driven

    Needs and Result Driven

    Project 

    Responsive

    Proactive

    Supportive

    Investment 

    Subjective

    Objective

    Mandatory and Discretionary

    Engagement

    Limited Engagement

    Extensive Engagement

    Holistic Engagement

    Major Areas of Focus

    Community cohesion, charity initiatives

    Individualistic approach, Equal access to opportunities 

    Responsive Capitalism, Legacy, developmental goals

    Significance of philanthropy as a development tool

    • Bridging Funding Gaps: Supplement critical budgetary support given by governments.
    • Addressing Development Gaps: Such as poverty alleviation, education, and healthcare access.
      • E.gAzim Premji Foundation enhances rural public education.
    • Catalyzing Innovation: Tech-driven initiatives like digital literacy programs/healthcare startups.
      • E.gBill & Melinda Gates Foundation focus on sanitation innovations aligning with Swachh Bharat Mission. 

    Ethical challenges in Philanthropy

    • Elite capture of social agenda: Experts argue that large donors may influence policy decisions thereby amplifying voices of the wealthy. Moreover, it is often used for tax evasion & money laundering activities.
    • Corporate Dilemma: Responsibility of businesses is to increase profits and philanthropy goes against shareholder's assets. 
    • Welfare Replacement: It may reduce government's accountability for welfare spending thereby shifting public responsibility to private actors
    • Regional and Geographical Inequality: Urban-centric donations (Maharashtra & Karnataka get maximum CSR funds, whereas Bihar & Odisha lag far behind)
      • Cultural & Religious Biases: Donors may favour causes which are in sync with personal beliefs.
    •  Accountability and Transparency Deficits: Miniscule amount of NGOs which receives foreign funding's file returns. There have been also restrictions on NGOs giving rise to debate of balancing sovereignty concerns versus development needs. 

    Conclusion

    Philanthropy should have foundations laid on ethical considerations of promoting an egalitarian society characterised by equity and justice. . Philanthropy's potential to reach to the bottom rung of the society, where hundreds of millions of our citizens live, where neither the state nor the markets can reach, should be rightly utilized to reach that very last citizen.

    The next generation of generosity must shift from Corporate Social Responsibility  donations to conviction-led investment, broad-based participation enabling democratized giving beyond elite circles and must be used as a tool to complement justice and bringing in systemic reforms rather than merely a temporary relief leading to effective altruism.

    Case Study

    A wealthy industrialist, Mr. X, donates ₹50 crore to build schools in rural areas, gaining public praise. Later, it's revealed he evaded taxes worth ₹30 crore and used the donation to improve his company's image while claiming tax benefits. Critics argue his philanthropy is a tool for personal gain, while supporters say the schools still benefit society.

    1. "Philanthropy driven by tax benefits is not charity but smart accounting." Critically examine this statement. How can Gandhi's "trusteeship" guide ethical corporate philanthropy in modern India, balancing profit and social good?
    2. "The increasing reliance of governments on private philanthropy for social welfare raises concerns about the erosion of state responsibility." Examine this statement in the context of India's development challenges.
    • Tags :
    • Philanthropy
    • India Philanthropy Report 2025
    Download Current Article
    Subscribe for Premium Features